12 April 2019

That Elusive Neutral Rate

By Michael J. Bazdarich, PhD

Last year, the Fed spent a lot of time and effort arguing that it needed to raise interest rates to get them back to “neutral” levels, to where they were no longer stimulating the economy. While stock market and global growth concerns have put this issue on the back burner, it is sure to resurface again soon. We believe the neutral rate level is a much more elusive concept than the Fed lets on and that the evidence suggests we are already at or above neutral rates.

What does the Fed mean when it says rates are still stimulative? It means rate levels are directly stimulating faster consumer and business spending, right? No, that is not what it means. A decline in interest rates can stimulate private spending, but only for a while. Economists typically estimate the lagged effects of rate declines as lasting from six months to two years. The last Fed rate cut was in 2008, and T-bond yields hit their lows in 2009. The stimulative effects of yields on spending growth ran out eight years ago or more.

Instead, what the Fed means is that rates are below their long-run “equilibrium”—or sustainable—levels. As an economy recovers from a recession or responds to a bout of stimulative policy, rising income and spending levels impart upward pressure on interest rates. The Fed—or any central bank—can counter that pressure and hold yields down only by providing more stimulus: pumping still more money and credit into the system to offset the internal pressures that would otherwise be raising yields.

However, such stimulus imposes ever-increasing strains on an economy. Spending is accelerated faster and faster, creating even more upward pressure on yields, thus requiring still more policy stimulus to prevent rates from rising. In this pressure-cooker environment, internal strains accumulate until the economy explodes, much as actually happened in the US in the 1970s.

The US economy currently exhibits no sign of such stresses. Bond yields have remained essentially flat despite years of supposedly below-neutral short rates and even four years of hikes in short rates. Bond yields have also held stable despite the fact that the Fed ceased injecting liquidity into the system five years ago. In fact, the Fed has been steadily withdrawing liquidity ever since then. Inflation remains stable despite widespread expectations—even hopes—for an acceleration. Nominal GDP (spending) growth itself has remained stable at a very low 4% to 5% rate throughout the 10 years of this expansion.

If the Fed were really below neutral, all these economic indicators would be showing ever-accelerating growth, and term yields would have started shooting up as soon as liquidity injections ceased. But no!

To repeat, the abiding belief that interest rates are below neutral or below normal is simply at odds with experience. It could well be that short rates have already peaked for this cycle and will be sustained at lower levels in the future.

Exhibit 1: Nominal GDP Growth and Inflation
Nominal GDP Growth and Inflation
Source: Bureau of Economic Analysis, data thru 31 Dec 18. Select the image to expand the view.
© Western Asset Management Company Ltd 2021. 当資料の著作権は、ウエスタン・アセット・マネジメント株式会社およびその関連会社(以下「ウエスタン・アセット」という)に帰属するものであり、ウエスタン・アセットの顧客、その投資コンサルタント及びその他の当社が意図した受取人のみを対象として作成されたものです。第三者への提供はお断りいたします。当資料の内容は、秘密情報及び専有情報としてお取り扱い下さい。無断で当資料のコピーを作成することや転載することを禁じます。
ウエスタン・アセット・マネジメント・カンパニーDTVM(Distribuidora de Títulos e Valores Mobiliários)リミターダ(ブラジル、サンパウロ拠点)はブラジル証券取引委員会(CVM)とブラジル中央銀行(Bacen)により認可され、また規制を受けます。ウエスタン・アセット・マネジメント・カンパニー・ピーティーワイ・リミテッド (ABN 41 117 767 923) (オーストラリア、メルボルン拠点)はオーストラリアの金融サービスライセンス303160を保有しています。ウエスタン・アセット・マネジメント・カンパニー・ピーティーイー・リミテッド(シンガポール拠点)は、キャピタル・マーケット・サービス(CMS)ライセンス (Co. Reg. No. 200007692R) を保有し、シンガポール通貨監督庁に監督されています。ウエスタン・アセット・マネジメント株式会社(日本拠点)は金融商品取引業者として登録され、日本の金融庁の規制を受けます。ウエスタン・アセット・マネジメント・カンパニー・リミテッド(英国、ロンドン拠点)は英金融行動監視機構(FCA)により認可され(FRN145930)、また規制を受けます。当資料は英国においては、FCAに定義された「プロフェッショナルな顧客」のみを対象とした宣伝目的に使用されるものです。また、許可を得ている特定の欧州経済領域(EEA)加盟国への配信を目的とする場合もあります。最新の承認済みEEA加盟国のリストについては、ウエスタン・アセット(電話:+44 (0)20 7422 30000)までお問い合わせください。
業務の種類: 金融商品取引業者(投資運用業、投資助言・代理業、第二種金融商品取引業)
登録番号: 関東財務局長(金商)第427号
加入協会: 一般社団法人日本投資顧問業協会(会員番号 011-01319)